Fuchs-Photography
Photos 2004-2010

Test: How fast are these cards really ?

Memory cards have become a lot cheaper and bigger in memory size over the last years. Compact Flash is still one of the most common, stable type amongst all Memory cards with a good ration Memory/Euro. Writing speed is claimed to be one of the biggest criteria when looking for a memory card and of course having spent already several thousand on your Photo Equipment one does not want to be a scrooge when it comes to purchasing the card. After all it should be the best one - right ?

So which one does the job? Looking for a speedy card today, you can find: Ultra, Ultra II, Extreme III, High Speed, Ultimate etc. The list of superlatives goes on and on depending on at which vendor you're looking.

Well, I had already collected some cards with my Canon 300D and with the purchase of the Canon 30D, Canon was so nice to give one SAN DISK 512MB away for free as part of their promotion. This was the chance to test this supposably "slow" card. The test setup was very easy: Tripod, focus on the bright sky to get a very short exposure time and then press the shutter button in continuous shooting mode until the Camera buffer is full, this until the moment the camera was finished writing the data on the card is the measured time you find listed below. Variations in JPG, JPG+RAW plus a test with the old Canon 300D to see the effect on a slower camera also.








NAME SAN DISK
Ultra II
SAN DISK
Ultra II
SAN DISK
Normal
KINGSTON
ELITE PRO
LEXAR
High Speed
CARD CF CF CF CF CF
MEMORY 512MB 2,0GB 512MB 512MB 256MB

Test with Canon EOS 30D continuous shooting in fast setting

# JPG 26 24 25 25 24
Time [sec] 17:94 21:79 16:88 24:32 22:38
# JPG+RAW 9 9 9 9 9
Time [sec] 18:00 20:19 18:00 25:40 23:18

Test with Canon EOS 300D continuous shooting (only SAN DISK 512MB compared)

# JPG 4   4

Time [sec] 16:25
16:09

# RAW 4   4

Time [sec] 32:00
32:00


Summary of this test:
As it turns out there is nothing "Ultra", "High Speed" or alike within these so called cards. The normal plain SAN DISK 512MB model does the job just as fine and in some occasions surprisingly even better than the faster brothers and sisters. The price difference is not so big actually whether you buy a fancy or a plain card but still it is interesting to see the marketing idea behind it.... :-)
Thank you Canon for this fast freebie card !






   

Home

Video

Links


    Back to Photography